This is from a Christianity Today interview with William Lane Craig:
As football fans prepare for the big game, what thought would you want to leave them with?
I think the overriding thing I want to say is God's providence rules all of life, even down to the smallest details. Nothing happens without either God's direct will or at least his permission of that event. That includes every fumble, every catch, every run. All of these things are in the providence of God, and therefore, we should not think that these things are a matter of indifference. These are of importance to God as well even though they seem trivial.
Craig is a well-known philosopher/theologian/apologist in evangelical Christian circles. Much of what he writes will make your head hurt. So who am I to disagree with him? Nevertheless, I do disagree, sort of . . .
I agree with his general statement, “Nothing happens without either God's direct will or at least his permission of that event.” So it is true that, in this sense (which allows for much in the way of “permission”) God does rule all of life. But this is not a good reason to conclude that we should not think things involved in each play of the Super Bowl might not be of at least relative indifference to God.
That we decide something like a football game will consume our attention, and for many, their resources, does not mean that God is necessarily concerned with every detail of that event – things like which team converts a key third down, for example. Perhaps God is a football fan, of sorts – how could we ever know that since He has decided to reveal nothing about it to us?
I have no doubt that God, as our Creator and Sustainer, has some level of interest in almost everything we do. But everything that God has revealed about Himself would indicate that, while He is completely aware of human spectacles like the Super Bowl, they are not the sorts of things about us that are in the important category to God. To give Craig his due, earlier in the interview he implied this, but here I thinks he jumps far beyond the evidence he presents for his conclusion.
There is nothing wrong with watching and enjoying a sporting event of almost any kind. But a sporting event, especially of the professional kind, is staged primarily to amuse ourselves. Again, some amount of amusement is not wrong. But in all likelihood, for many people, the kinds of things surrounding something like a Super Bowl that would most concern God would be matters other than the details of game play.
God is concerned about those who wasted more of their resources on sports than on the kingdom of heaven. God might think it important that so many people can think of nothing but a sporting event for several weeks, to the exclusion of their knowledge of and relationship with Him. God might very interested in the fact that some of us think more of our favorite sports hero than we do of Him. God could well think it quite important that so many of the events surrounding a Super Bowl include all sorts of rank immorality – sometimes, especially, the half-time show.
Therefore, Dr. Craig, I must disagree, sort of. (P.S. – I plan to watch the game tonight, at least until it gets boring, which I don’t expect this one will. I will even enjoy some of the creative commercials. I won’t watch the half-time shows. Even when they are not tawdry, or even pornographic, they are too often just idiotic.)